How Social Media Is Affecting Young Athletes’ Confidence and Performance
Social media gives young athletes more access, exposure, and inspiration than ever before. It can also create unrealistic expectations around progress, success, playing time, and how athletes see themselves.
The Core Idea
Young athletes need confidence, but confidence must remain connected to honest self-evaluation. When comparison begins shaping an athlete’s expectations, parents and coaches have an opportunity to redirect them toward ownership and growth.
Social media has changed the way young athletes experience sports. Athletes now have constant access to highlights, rankings, scholarship offers, championship moments, training videos, and other players their own age performing at extremely high levels.
There are benefits to that access. Athletes can learn, become inspired, discover new training ideas, and see what may be possible for them. The challenge is that they are often comparing their everyday development to someone else’s best moments.
A study of 591 adolescent athletes across 42 sports found that longer daily social media use was associated with greater negative affect and dysfunctional eating patterns. Researchers found that social comparison and sleep quality helped explain those relationships.
Athletes competing at higher performance levels also reported greater levels of social comparison.
Research source: PubMed – Social Media Use in Adolescent Athletes
Another longitudinal study followed 356 adolescent athletes between the ages of 14 and 18 and found relationships between appearance-focused social media use, body dissatisfaction, and competitive anxiety. Those relationships were particularly important among younger athletes between 14 and 16 years old.
The concern is not simply that kids are spending too much time on their phones. The larger issue is what repeated comparison may begin teaching them about themselves.
Research following adolescent athletes over time found connections between appearance-focused social media engagement, body dissatisfaction, and competitive anxiety, with younger adolescent athletes appearing especially vulnerable.
Research source: PubMed – Social Media, Body Dissatisfaction and Competitive Anxiety
When Athletes See the Outcome Without the Process
Social media allows athletes to see the result without seeing everything required to produce it. They see the scholarship offer, but not the years of work before it. They see the highlight, but not the mistakes, correction, failure, repetition, and ordinary practices that came before it.
Over time, this can create an unrealistic expectation of where an athlete believes they should be. Playing time, recognition, rankings, team status, and external attention can begin to feel like evidence of whether they are succeeding or failing.
At One Family Athletics, we believe young athletes should have high expectations for themselves. We want them to pursue excellence, believe they can improve, and understand what they are capable of becoming.
High expectations, however, still have to remain connected to reality. An athlete should be able to believe strongly in who they can become while remaining honest about where they currently are.
Teaching Athletes to Ask the Correct WHY
One of the concepts we teach at One Family Athletics is asking the correct WHY. When athletes experience disappointment, the question they ask next can either protect their current perception of themselves or help them grow.
Instead of immediately asking, “Why is my coach not playing me?” the better question may be, “What does my coach need to see from me to trust me more?”
Instead of asking, “Why is that athlete getting the opportunity?” ask, “What are they currently doing that I need to improve?”
The wrong WHY protects the ego.
The correct WHY creates ownership.
This distinction is especially important in an environment where athletes are constantly seeing other people celebrated online. Confidence should not require an athlete to convince themselves that they are further along than they really are.
Healthy confidence allows an athlete to recognize where they need to improve without allowing that weakness, correction, or setback to define who they are.
Parents Can Get Pulled Into the Same Cycle
Parents are not immune to this environment. Certain clubs, leagues, rankings, teams, and opportunities carry status in youth sports. Without realizing it, a parent can begin protecting the status of their athlete rather than supporting the development of their athlete.
There are absolutely situations where parents should advocate for their children. But when every disappointing outcome is blamed on a coach, politics, another athlete, or the environment, we can unintentionally teach young athletes to look outward before ever looking inward.
Youth sports should be one of the places where young people learn how to receive correction, navigate disappointment, evaluate themselves honestly, take ownership, and continue growing.
Questions Parents Can Start Asking
Parents do not have to solve every disappointment or immediately convince their child that they are right. Sometimes the most valuable thing we can do is create a conversation that helps an athlete slow down, reflect honestly, and take ownership of what comes next.
What are you doing well right now, and what still needs to improve?
This helps athletes hold confidence and honest self-evaluation at the same time. Both are necessary for healthy development.
What has your coach been asking you to improve lately?
This shifts attention away from whether the athlete agrees with every decision and toward whether they are listening, learning, and responding to feedback.
When you see another athlete doing something you want to accomplish, what can you learn from them?
Comparison does not always have to create insecurity. Parents can help athletes turn comparison into curiosity and development.
Is there something you are blaming on someone else that you actually have some control over?
This is where ownership begins. Athletes learn to separate what they cannot control from the effort, attitude, preparation, and response they can.
Social media will continue showing young athletes the finished product.
Our responsibility is to help them understand the process required to become it.
The Parent Playbook
One Family Athletics helps parents, coaches, and organizations create youth sports environments where athletes develop confidence, ownership, identity, emotional control, and the ability to grow through pressure.
If you are interested, reach out to Greg at greg@onefamathletics.com and he will get you more information.
Ask About Parent Playbook